Earlier this month, in Richmond, Virginia, the statue of Jefferson Davis, the president of the Confederacy, was toppled. It had stood on Monument Avenue since 1907. Virginia’s governor had already announced he would remove the 60-foot tall statue of Robert E. Lee, the figurative centerpiece of this avenue dedicated to Confederate leaders. But as evidenced by the messages written on that statue over the last few weeks, the Governor’s announcement was too little, too late for those protesting the brutal murder of George Floyd and championing what is beginning to be fully understood: Black Lives Matter.
Any child of the South, as I am, knows the statues weren’t only to celebrate the leadership of the Confederacy. The statues were to celebrate white supremacy. Most of these icons were erected between the late 1800s and the early 1900s. They were intended to underscore that the South may have lost the war, but in other ways, they had won. The sentiments of the South—the true belief of most white leaders across America at the time — was that white supremacy/leadership would not be threatened by the mere act of ending slavery. That message was delivered powerfully through legislation and actions — Jim Crow laws, lynchings, and the prominence of the Ku Klux Klan — along with the construction of these massive statues.
Now, roughly a century after that period in history, citizens are calling for a reckoning. The Jim Crow laws, lynchings and prominence of white supremacy have been largely camouflaged in modern times, as Michelle Alexander revealed in her book, The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness. Policies and practices to maintain the predominance of white rule, white privilege, white supremacy have been prettied up, as my Dad used to say. Look carefully though, and you can see where and how institutions and systems routinely give white people advantages over black people.
But you don’t have to delve deeply for symbols of the Confederacy. Confederate statues are abundant. Confederate flags are flown proudly across the country, even included in the Mississippi state flag. The image is displayed on bumper stickers and incorporated into clothing. The statues and Confederate memorabilia were/are intended as a reminder of the underpinnings of the Old South and that the South — at least its philosophy on race — could rise again. But, today, in many quarters, even that iconography is beginning to be relegated to the past.
In 1945, after World War II, the Allies banned all symbols of the Nazi regime. Flags were destroyed. Statues were taken down. Displaying the swastika was declared a crime. Nazis deemed criminals were sought, arrested and tried at Nuremberg. Everything that celebrated Hitler and his thinking disappeared from Germany. There was clarity. The philosophy of white Aryan superiority might continue to live in the psyches of some Germans. But, there would be no public venues created to celebrate what the government saw as the most shameful time in its nation’s history.
When an end to apartheid came to South Africa, there were trials—truth and reconciliation. The oppressed and the oppressor were brought together to acknowledge the pain and try to move the country to heal.
In the (re)United States, not only were there no real punishments* for the South after the war, the sentiments of the South seemed to shape the post-war values of the entire country. The government of America has never addressed the racial core of the Civil War. That’s the crux of the issue: America has never come to terms with slavery as this country’s original sin nor has it recognized the ongoing subjugation of black people.
Maybe until now.
Today, we, the people, are proclaiming it is time for that day of reckoning. The tearing down of these statues is a beginning, moving the country from the symbolic dismantling of the Confederacy to substance: an examination and re-calibration of all the elements of America: health care, education, housing laws and practices, banking and business, the judicial system, and so much more. All that underpins how America operates and ensures the advantaging of one race over another must change.
The dictionary says that the day of reckoning is “the time when one is called on to account for one’s actions, to pay one’s debts, or to fulfill one’s promises or obligations.” That sounds right to me.
*Note: The forty acres promised to formerly enslaved people to start their new lives was to come from 400,000 acres confiscated from Southern landowners by the federal government. That would have constituted a punishment, maybe even the beginning of reparations, but that land was ultimately returned to the original owners.
9 Replies to “Confederate statues and the day of reckoning … from symbolism to substance”
A very clear and powerful reckoning on this issue. You strip away all the excuses for not acting for change. You are absolutely right that we have never acknowledged what slavery has represented in this country. That paragraph was an “ah ha” moment for me.
Thanks so Much
Thank you for continuing to teach us with your historical lessons, moral clarity, and call to action, Tamara.
So… I didn’t know about Hitler symbols and Germany until this week. Wow. Wow. Wow. Thanks for putting the statues in context.
Even the National Trust for Historic Preservation has declared that it’s time to remove them! In Charleston, SC, the statue of John C Calhoun may, at long last, be coming down.
Excellent piece, Tamara, as always.
Thank you Tamara, for this wonderful article.
We must acknowledge the injuries inflicted, find ways to reconcile, and pay the long overdue debt. And we shouldn’t waste this opportunity to do the hard work. (BTW, I like the aspiration for the (re)United States.) Maybe we can learn how to go about this from South Africa, Germany, and others.
Thank you Tamara. I appreciate the history and the education.
Tamara- once again you hit the nail on the head. symbols and statues do matter and send a continued message that this country is still a long way from equality and a true putting of our past behind us . Mississippi Flag change and focus on W&L University naming along with the removal of the late 1800’s and eaRLY 2oth century abject symbols of racism and revisionist history of the Stars and Bars even up here in WNY where the display of same is a clear and present negative message and shouldnt be tolerated and the coward at 1600 PA ave touts the wrongheaded ideology he spouted after Charlottesville makes the journey that much more difficult. keep up the good fight and persevere . PEACE!